29 Apr New Family Procedure Rules mean court should not be the first option

The rules come into force on Monday 29th April 2024. This means prior to applying to court to start formal court proceedings (with court hearings taking place regarding division of the finances arising from a divorce or the arrangements for children), non-court dispute resolutions (NCRD) options have to be considered and explored and evidence of their use needs to be provided to the court. However, if there is domestic abuse then this may exempt a person from having to engage NCRD.
Judges will want to know why a person has applied to court and why non court dispute resolution options were not used or if used why they did not assist and why an application to court is needed.
Once court proceedings have been started, the parties and the court are to keep under review whether the proceedings should be adjourned so a non court dispute resolution option can be used, or whether a non court dispute resolution option should be used alongside the court proceedings.
There could be cost implications for parties who are involved in court proceedings over the division of the finances due to a divorce, if they failed, without justification, to engage in NCRD options e.g. the party who failed to engage could be ordered to pay some of the other parties’ costs.
So what are non court dispute resolution (NCDR) options:
- Mediation involves the separated couple meeting together to talk through the issues with a mediator. Issues such as how are the financial matters going to be resolved and divided, what are the arrangements going to be for the children who will they live with and how much time will they spend with the other person etc. The role of the mediator is to be neutral and to help you both talk about the issues in a constructive way to help you both reach an agreement. The mediator cannot provide legal advice and so legal advice may need to be sought from solicitors in advance of the mediation sessions or afterwards;
- This involves both parties and their lawyers meeting together and working as a team to resolve the issues, everyone agrees to work together in a respectful, cooperative, open and honest way. Collaborative means that you both have the benefit of having your lawyers present to give you both advice, you can come up with options which work best for you and your family, you can be more creative than a judge, working together in a collaborative way will help you and your family, especially if you have children together and will be involved in one another’s lives after separation due to this.
- A person is appointed to decide the issues, information is presented to the arbitrator in writing or orally and then the arbitrator decides for you both. The decision of the arbitrator is binding;
- Early Neutral Evaluation/Private Financial dispute resolution. A person is appointed to decide the issue, normally a lawyer or former judge, you both choose the person, then information is presented to the person, and they then indicate what the answer should be after considering the information or hearing from your own lawyers. This means you both decide the “judge”, it can take place on a date which suits you both, and so avoids the delays of court and the gamble of not knowing which court judge you will get. The indication is not binding but can assist people in reaching an agreement.
The above are just some of the NCDR options.
The rules have for a long time tried to encourage people to resolve their disputes without starting court proceedings, however some people have paid lip service to this and their preference has been to argue it out in court, without trying to resolve matters. This means the courts are clogged up with applications, leading to delays. Also, the straight jacket of the tools a judge has are not always best for you and your family and can lead to worse outcomes than if you had both reached an agreement with the help of a NCDR option. The new rules however put the focus on NCDR with people having to justify why they have not been used, and the risk of criticism from a judge if they have failed to use them, and possible cost implications.
Please remember if you reach an agreement about your finances, arising from a divorce then this will need to be recorded in a court order, this can be sent into a judge to approve, without court proceedings.
Please contact me if you are separating so I can help you move forward, and discuss the potential ways of doing this for you. You can contact me, Genette Gale, by calling 01747 852377 or emailing me at g.gale@rutterslaw.co.uk. I am a family solicitor and a collaborative family lawyer.

